Terminal
Terminal/Skill
Compares a branch or PR's code graph before and after the change, flagging new entry points, removed auth checks, and new tainted paths.
By Trail of Bits
Works with
npx skills add trailofbits/skills --skill trailmark-review-gateApply deterministic security gate rules to Trailmark structural diff evidence. This skill does not replace line-level review. It produces a compact structural packet reviewers can cite while they inspect the code.
trailmark or trailmark-structural.differential-review.trailmark-finding-triage.| Rationalization | Why It Is Wrong | Required Action |
|---|---|---|
| "The line diff is small, so no graph gate is needed" | Small changes can create new call paths | Compare before/after graphs |
| "Graph gate passed, so the PR is secure" | The gate only checks structural regressions | Still perform line-level review |
| "Trailmark failed, so pass the gate" | Tool failure is unknown risk, not success | Emit UNKNOWN |
| "Tests pass, so removed validation is fine" | Tests may miss affected entrypoint paths | Review the removed path manually |
| "Only new code matters" | Removed auth, validation, and callers can be higher risk than additions | Review removals and path changes |
Review Gate Progress:
- [ ] Step 1: Resolve before/after inputs
- [ ] Step 2: Build graph-evolution evidence
- [ ] Step 3: Normalize structural changes
- [ ] Step 4: Apply gate rules
- [ ] Step 5: Emit review packet and actions
Accept two refs, a branch name, a commit range, or before/after directories.
Do not check out branches unnecessarily. Prefer git diff, git show, and
git worktrees, following the graph-evolution snapshot workflow.
Run graph-evolution or equivalent Trailmark before/after graph analysis.
Both snapshots must run engine.preanalysis() so taint, privilege-boundary,
blast-radius, complexity, and entrypoint signals are available.
Record Trailmark version and any feature probes. If graph construction fails,
emit UNKNOWN.
Normalize evidence into:
Apply the rules in references/gate-rules.md. Gate verdicts are:
| Verdict | Meaning |
|---|---|
FAIL | A high-risk structural regression needs review before acceptance |
WARN | A meaningful graph change needs reviewer attention |
PASS | No configured structural gate fired |
UNKNOWN | Trailmark failed or evidence is too incomplete |
Write the packet using
references/output-format.md, then hand it to
the branch reviewer. Use
references/review-integration.md when
combining this packet with differential-review or another PR review process.
PASS when Trailmark failed.FAIL and WARN.